1st Online Conference
- Home
- 1st Online Conference
Ibn-E-Sina 1st Online Conference Report
Ibn-E-Sina Research and Development Organization (ISRDO) launched its first online conference via Zoom on December 18, 2022 which attended by Schiller Institute experts and Afghan diaspora and Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan in charges.
In this conference which was launched via Zoom many experts from Schiller Institute presented theirs plans based on their expertise with full details which we believe can lead Afghanistan to be self-Sufficient and stand by itself.
Presentations of Schiller Institute experts:
- Transport
- Food, Agriculture & Transformation
- Electricity
- Banking
- Health system
The above important topics were presented by the experts which in here I would like to bring the speech of Mr. Wolfgang Lillge who presented the health system “the core part of Ibn-E-Sina operations.”
Empowering the Health System
The development of a modern health care system in Afghanistan through the eyes of Ibn Sina.
My name is Dr. Wolfgang Lillge from Berlin, I am a trained physician, but my main activity was and is in the field of science journalism. For many years I have been the editor-in-chief of the German-language science magazine Fusion, which promotes the development of future technologies in all areas of science.
When we want to develop a modern healthcare system in Afghanistan, it doesn’t just mean planning hospitals, doctors’ offices or healthcare personnel. Healthcare in any nation is always an integral part of the overall economic activity, especially energy, water and industrial infrastructure.
In our report, we asked what the great physician, scientist and philosopher Ibn Sina would do today when he would see the country of his father’s suffering. The first thing he would do would be to bring out his canon of medicine and extend it to the present day.
pix Avicenna canon
In particular, he would emphasize, even then, the need for facilities for personal hygiene and disinfection to prevent the spread of germs – centuries before Pasteur and the development of microbiology.
Ibn Sina, whom I learned in the department History of Medicine while studying medicine in Germany, was for good reasons considered the greatest physician in human history, whose canon of medicine guided physicians in the Islamic world and Europe for over 600 years.
Ibn Sina’s principles are still valid today: a public health system can only function if basic requirements of hygiene are met – clean drinking water and a sewage system so that people do not come into contact with dirty water and feces.
pix dirty water
In fact, dirty water is the leading cause of death in an undeveloped or war-torn society. At the same time, however, providing clean drinking water is the most effective way to drastically reduce mortality, especially among children, a good example of this is the situation in Afghanistan itself.
The World Health Organization estimates that more than 133 Afghan children die every day from diarrheal diseases (as of 2014). That’s more than 48,000 children per year. In contrast, the number of Afghan deaths attributed to the war was just over 3,000 in 2011, meaning that fifteen times more children die each year from an extremely common and easily treated disease than the total number of men, women, and children killed in the war.
Thus, polluted water resulted in 15 times as many deaths among children alone compared to the total population killed during of the armed conflict.
An example to the contrary is the situation in China, where the water infrastructure was systematically developed.
China Graph
In China there is a clear correlation between the proportion of the rural population with access to piped water and the mean incidence of reportable waterborne infectious diseases between 1990 and 2020.
As you can see in the grapic, in 1990, the proportion of the rural population in China with piped water access was only about 30%; by 2020, this proportion had increased to nearly 80%. During the same period, the number of waterborne infectious diseases (caused by enterobacteria and viruses) decreased from 90 per 100,000 population to less than 10 per 100,000 population.
In addition to clean drinking water, a comprehensive sewage system is just as important. Every household must have a flush toilet so that wastewater and feces can be channeled through the sewage system to a treatment plant. Only treated wastewater may be released back into the rivers or lakes. Otherwise, the cycle between contaminated water, diarrheal diseases and high mortality cannot be broken.
The third pillar of public health that Ibn Sina emphasized is a healthy diet that makes the human immune system resistant to disease.
The current nutritional situation in Afghanistan demands immediate intervention by the global community, because building a functioning health care system is impossible as long as more than half of the Afghan population is starving – the direct result of the devastation left by U.S. and NATO forces after their withdrawal.
IMMEDIATE ACTION
Immediate action is needed to improve the situation in Afghanistan. The World Food Program for Afghanistan estimated in its October 2022 Situation Report No. 31 that humanitarian assistance – food, medicine, fuel, shelter, safe water, livelihood assistance – is needed for 25 million people in Afghanistan. In March 2022, the United Nations requested $4.4 billion to provide humanitarian and medical assistance for the year, but as of August, only $1.8 billion had been received.
Medical and health-related supplies must be delivered urgently, preferably through bilateral agreements to provide medicines, vaccines, water decontamination equipment, food, fuel, and a system for sharing knowledge with other doctors worldwide.
For immediate medical care, the ad hoc network of remaining hospitals in the country needs to be expanded, including the five clinics operated by MSF, the Turkmenistan-funded hospitals in western Afghanistan, the Indira Gandhi Children’s Hospital in Kabul, and other such facilities. It would also need to be clarified which of the former 2300 clinics in the World Bank-funded Sehatmandi project are still available after the project is scheduled to be discontinued by the World Bank in June 2022.
All options must be exhausted to provide additional medical facilities. Military-style field hospitals and clinics can be established, possibly in conjunction with sites where the World Food Program operates logistics depots for the UN Humanitarian Air Service. These depots are located in Fayzabad, Kabul, Kandahar, Kunduz, Herat, Jalalabad, Mazar-i-Sharif, Bamyan, and Maymana.
All means must be used to combat infectious diseases – from vaccines to decontaminated water and hygiene measures, pesticides, nutritional supplements, etc. Besides Covid-19, virtually all infectious and parasitic diseases continue to spread – malaria, dengue, tuberculosis, measles and others. For example, measles is prevalent in all 34 Afghan provinces. A special effort to eradicate polio should be supported by the entire world, because Pakistan and Afghanistan are the last countries where the poliovirus is still rampant.
Support for immediate medical projects can hardly be expected at present from the Western world, which would actually have a deep moral obligation to rebuild Afghanistan, but instead they are freezing Afghan foreign funds. Immediate efforts should be made to secure financial pledges from an alliance of friendly neighboring states in Central and East Asia, as well as assistance from organizations such as the Red Cross, the Red Crescent and the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, which opened an office in Kabul on Nov. 13, 2022, to expand humanitarian and economic aid.
Pledges have already come from six neighboring countries (Iran, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Pakistan and China) after a March 2022 meeting in Tunxi, China. The final document stated, “China will honor its commitment to provide emergency humanitarian assistance to Afghanistan and provide humanitarian assistance such as food, winter supplies, COVID-19 vaccines, and medical equipment, and China is willing to provide additional humanitarian assistance through bilateral and multilateral channels…. [China] will support the operation of Afghanistan’s medical and health systems….”
The Ibn Sina Brigade Under the current provisional conditions and until a full public health capacity is built, we propose to pursue the concept of the Ibn Sina Brigade. By this we mean a mix of medical professionals and volunteers who will survey the health situation throughout the country and provide basic medical care and improve the hygiene situation with simple tools.
The top priority is to train doctors. Statistically, there are not even 0.3 doctors per 1,000 people in Afghanistan. By comparison, Uzbekistan has 2.37 and Cuba more than 5 doctors per 1,000 inhabitants. To achieve this, large training centers – Ibn Sina faculties in large cities – must be built to train thousands of new doctors over the next ten years. Trained doctors in the diaspora should also be motivated to return home. The same training applies to all other specialties, from nursing to medical technicians, laboratory experts and so on. The training of female doctors has increased in Afghanistan in the last year. Which is important to comply with Sharia law, which provides that only female doctors should treat female patients.
Many health workers need to be recruited and trained in the communities. They must fill the shortage of medical personnel, which will continue for some time. The goal is to integrate as many young people as possible into productive and useful professions in order to train them and at the same time deploy them in the health sector. In this way, they can serve society in various health care functions while completing their own vocational training.
Ibn Sina brigades can be used primarily to perform various tasks in rural areas related to filtration and decontamination of water, establishment of sewage and wastewater treatment plants in order to reduce waterborne diseases such as typhoid, cholera, coli, and salmonella. Community health workers can also be used to monitor and detect possible water contamination and identify contacts in the event of an infectious disease outbreak.
A major problem is also the treatment of heroin addicts and the overall presence of drugs – a relic of the long occupation by American and NATO troops. Up to 10 percent of the Afghan population is addicted, and methamphetamines are increasingly playing a role. All drug addicts must be freed from addiction and reintegrated into society. And the complete eradication of opium poppy cultivation, transportation and drug use in Afghanistan is in the immediate, direct interest of all nations in the region. Affected farmers must be supported with alternative cultivation options
Future prospects
The long-term goal in Afghanistan is to build a modern health care system with a network of clinics and doctors, diagnostic and treatment facilities of all kinds, and comprehensive public health capacities – water treatment, sanitation, pest control, food safety and the like.
An important benchmark in this regard is the number of modern hospital beds per thousand inhabitants. In certain regions, the recommended ratio of beds per thousand population may be around 2 to 5 (depending on transport time to facilities). A better ratio would be 3 to 6 beds per thousand to be prepared for acute disease outbreaks or natural disasters. The World Health Organization currently recommends 3 beds per thousand.
In Afghanistan, there are far fewer than half a bed per thousand, according to available figures. In 2017, the country had 0.39 beds per thousand, according to statistical estimates. By comparison, Uzbekistan has 4.4 beds per thousand population. This means that 250,000 modern hospital beds will need to be created in the coming years, up from the less than 16,000 in 2020.
Although it may sound utopian at the moment, this target should still be aimed for in the future development of the country.
A modern healthcare system functions in such a way that a patient’s first contact is with a local physician or a community nurse. If necessary, the patient is referred to a specialist or an outpatient clinic. For emergencies, patients can be transferred to different clinical departments for immediate diagnosis and treatment. Local hospitals are directly or indirectly linked to research and training centers to make clinical experience and expertise accessible everywhere.
Hospitals should be built in all provinces and districts to avoid excessive travel or transportation time for treatment. University hospitals serve as a link between teaching and practice, where the best doctors and scientists and their students work.
The long-term goal is a ratio of 4.5 physicians per 1000 population. Therefore, the national training program under Operation Ibn Sina must be launched and expanded as soon as possible.
In our report, we gave some examples for additional health care options available in the age of space and the Internet. One of these is “teleconsultation” between medical centers and local doctors. Wherever rural doctors are scarce, medical vehicles can be sent to remote areas with important medical instruments on board, especially imaging equipment, which can be connected to specialists at medical centers via Internet technology.
Another spinoff of space travel is the use of drones for medical purposes. This means that for instance blood reserves or important medicines can be brought quickly to remote locations where they are needed. That is already being tested in Africa, and Afghanistan will soon be able to figure out how it works for them.
pix Ibn Sina
This is what Ibn Sina would do if he were alive today.
Thank you